From a reader who takes my thoughts below to a more theological level. Something which is usually badly needed."What we have hear is a failure to trust the liturgy."
Oh, I like that. But I think the symptoms are of a greater failing.
The Mass is not about the assembled community. Nor is it even about the assembled community praying to God.
The Mass is the Son's prayer to the Father.
The priest is not acting in persona Christi just toward us; he is also acting in persona Christi toward God. If he's offering a sacrifice, he must be offering it to someone. And the sacrifice he's offering, with the assembly's assistance, is the Sacrifice Jesus offered His Father on the Cross.
This is why neither the priest nor anyone else is free to monkey about with the Liturgy (including the Liturgy of the Hours). Not because it violates canon law or the bishop's instructions or the rulings of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments,but because it is nothing less than Christ's prayer to the Father.
What we need to do, it seems obvious to me, is to celebrate Mass in a way that incorporates us -- and the etymology of "incorporates" is significant here -- into the prayer of Christ to the Father. What we must not do is use the Mass as an excuse to pray to the Father apart from Christ, much less as a community-building exercise.
I think American Catholics have a peculiar problem: We are Mass-centered to such an extent that we try to fit every possible corporate religious expression between the processional and the recessional Sunday morning. There are things that we want to do, maybe have to do, as a community that simply do not fit into the Mass. The
proper thing to do is to do them outside the Mass, but the idea of getting Catholics to come to church for something other than a Mass --for a private devotion, say, or some sort of parish prayer service --has largely fallen out of our culture, apart from Christmas concerts during Advent. [ed's note: Heh.]
We are shrinking two ways at once by both forgetting what the Mass is and forgetting how to pray as a group outside of Mass. Doing the former means we don't notice the problem with doing the latter.
Words, I must say, to tape on your parish liturgist's bathroom mirror. If, that is, you can push him/her aside from his/her morning "Thank you God for Making Me so Fabulous" ritual time in front of it.